9 Pizza Places in Youngstown, Ohio

December 24th, 2020 by

Sometimes nothing hits the spot quite like a slice of delicious pizza. Fortunately, there are a variety of places around Youngstown, Ohio, where you can find your favorite pies. Whether you’re in the mood for classic pepperoni or something unique, you’ll find the perfect slice when you visit these best pizza places around Youngstown.

Avalon Downtown

pepperoni pizza close up

Image via Flickr by LifeSupercharger

Avalon Downtown is a hip pizza joint located in the heart of downtown Youngstown. Here you’ll find some of your favorite cooked-to-order options. One popular option is the Briar Hill, which includes tomato sauce, sweet peppers, and imported Romano cheese. To enjoy some international flair with your pizza, consider the Mad Greek, which includes sauteed spinach, garlic, Kalamata olives, and feta cheese, or the Taste of Italy, which has tomato sauce, capicola, salami, pepperoni, prosciutto, and mozzarella cheese. The restaurant can even accommodate special diets thanks to its gluten-free and cauliflower crusts.

Cornersburg Pizza

If you’re interested in trying a pizza you won’t find on every menu, head to Cornersburg Pizza and order the Pickle Pizza. This unique pie includes butter sauce, pickle slices, mozzarella and Romano cheeses, garlic, and dill weed. If you prefer something a little more traditional, the pizza shop has you covered. One popular option is Mrs. Lu’s Special, which includes tomato sauce, green peppers, sausage, onions, Romano cheese, garlic, basil, and oregano. If you’re feeling creative, you can also choose from the delicious selection of fresh toppings and make your own pizza.

Belleria Pizza & Italian Restaurant

Belleria Pizza & Italian Restaurant has several locations around Youngstown, which makes it easy to order your favorite slice no matter where you are in the city. If you’re feeling extra hungry, consider getting one of their tasty appetizers. Good options include cheese sticks, homemade garlic breadsticks, or loaded fries, which are hand-cut fries topped with cheese, bacon, and ranch dressing. When it’s time to order your pizza, you can’t go wrong with one of the specialty options.

For something spicy, go with the Sausage Diablo Pizza, which includes hot sausage, hot peppers, and a blend of four cheeses. If you’re in the mood for something sweet and savory, you’ll love the Hawaiian Pizza that includes bacon, ham, pineapple, barbecue sauce, and a blend of cheeses. You can even order the Pizza Fritta for dessert. This delicious treat is made with homemade dough, deep-fried, and rolled in your choice of sugar or cinnamon and sugar.

Uptown Pizza

At Uptown Pizza, you can make your own pizza when you choose from toppings that include sausage, pepperoni, seasoned chicken, anchovies, bacon, ham, black olives, mushrooms, fresh tomatoes, hot peppers, onions, and more. You can also choose to order one of the specialty pizzas. Mark’s Favorite comes with everything except the anchovies, and Starr’s Favorite is topped with chicken, bacon, and garlic. The restaurant also offers spaghetti, ravioli, rigatoni, chicken Parmesan, and sandwiches.

Wedgewood Fernando’s Pizza

Wedgewood Fernando’s Pizza uses the same recipes and pizza-making process developed by Pasquate “Patsy” Acconcia and Fernando Riccioni over 50 years ago. The process begins every morning at 6 a.m. when the chefs start making the fresh pizza dough. All of the pizzas are made to order using the restaurant’s special sauce and unique toppings.

One popular option is the Fernando’s Special, which is a white pizza with red roasted sweet peppers, hot peppers, black olives, Italian sausage, bacon, and mozzarella cheese. Another delicious option is the barbecue chicken pizza, which includes sweet barbecue sauce, onions, chicken, and mozzarella cheese. Don’t forget to save room for a cinnamon pizza or caramel apple pizza for dessert!

The Elmton

While The Elmton is famous for its broasted chicken, the restaurant also serves up some delicious pizza. Consider starting your meal with the bacon cheese fries, pizza rolls with sauce, cheese sticks, or onion rings. When you’re ready for your pizza, you can choose from classic cheese or white cheese. You then get to decide which toppings you want. Your options include bacon, sausage, pepperoni, hot peppers, olives, onions, peppers, mushrooms, and broccoli. If you’re looking for a good deal, stop by on Tuesday to take advantage of the restaurant’s special price on a 16-inch pizza.

Westgate Pizza Company

Westgate Pizza Company has been satisfying pizza cravings in the Youngstown area since 1970. The pizza shop has one location in Austintown and one location in Boardman. Your pizza options include either 12 or 24 slices, so this is the place to go if you’re feeding a crowd. One popular specialty pizza is the garlic chicken, which includes garlic oil, chicken breast, fried peppers, Parmesan, and mozzarella. Another customer favorite is the three-meat combo, which has bacon, sausage, pepperoni, and mozzarella.

Rise Pies

Rise Pies serves up high-quality pizza using homemade recipes and fresh ingredients. Once the restaurant pops the pizza in its 600-degree WoodStone oven, you only have to wait 160 seconds until you have the perfect slice of pizza in front of you. The menu includes so many options that everyone will find something they love.

If you’re in the mood for something traditional, go with the classic Pepperoni Lovers pizza. Did you arrive with an appetite? The Supreme pizza with its Italian tomato sauce, pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, bell peppers, red onion, and shredded mozzarella is sure to fill you up. Plus, with three doughs, eight sauces, eight cheeses, and over 25 different toppings, you’ll have no problems creating your own pizza masterpiece.

Inner Circle Pizza Boardman – Poland

Located just south of Youngstown in Poland, Inner Circle Pizza Boardman – Poland serves freshly made pizzas, calzones, subs, wings, and more. You can order one of the specialty pizzas, such as the spinach, spinacoli, or vegetable pizza. You can also choose from a nice variety of toppings and build your own. Don’t forget to stop by on Wednesday for the cheese pizza special and swing by on the first Friday of every month for a special price on 12-inch pizzas.

When the only thing that will satisfy your hunger is a fresh slice of pizza, we think you’ll find exactly what you want when you visit one of these best pizza places around Youngstown. Did we miss your favorite? Then please contact us so we can add it to our list!

Posted in Uncategorized